Audrey Robinson

Audrey knew about Cyrus' anger, and him taking and killing blacks in 1963. Martin also told her about the time Cyrus came for him, but that he ended up killing Cyrus instead. That Clayton Soames and Jimmy Anderson helped Martin stuff Cyrus' body in the truck and pushed it into the swamp. She also knew that the young deputy Harold Todd found out about Cyrus' murder, but that he didn't arrest Martin because he also knew about Cyrus' killings. She keeps all this a secret, to protect all the men involved.

Early May 2006, Audrey's husband Martin tells her he is seeing Cyrus' old black truck following him, appearing and disappearing. This upsets her, as Martin is then killed in a car accident. Cassie invites some friends over, and they want to ask Audrey some questions, but she is too distraught and refuses to answer, heading upstairs instead.

After Cassie sees the black truck threatening her from outside, Audrey sits in the living room with her and the two young men, Dean and Sam Winchester. Sam asks her if Martin saw the truck before he died, but she tries to brush it off. Dean presses her, pointing out that Cassie could die, so she confesses Martin did see Cyrus Dorian's black truck. Audrey tells of her past, dating Cyrus and Martin, but breaking it off with Cyrus to marry Martin and how much Cyrus hated blacks. How people of color were disappearing into a black truck. How, on the date set for the wedding, the church they were to be married at burned down, with a children's choir all burned. She is becoming more and more upset, crying as she is trying to talk. There was one more attack, when Cyrus came for Martin. But Martin got loose and started hitting Cyrus, eventually killing him. He called on his friends Clayton Soames and Jimmy Anderson, and they put Cyrus' body into the truck. They rolled it into the swamp at the edge of his land, and all three of them kept that secret all these years. Dean asks why Mayor Todd isn't a racist, and she replies that he did nothing after finding out what Martin had done, because of what Cyrus had done. She didn't tell Cassie, because she thought she was protecting them, but now there's no one left to protect. Dean disagrees with her - there is Cassie to protect.

After Dean and Sam deal with the ghost truck and save Cassie, Audrey tells Cassie to tell them "Thank you" again.