It does not say Federal Bureau of Investigation on Dean and Sam's FBI badges. That's because even if it's just being made for a prop on a TV show, it is illegal to make a fake FBI badge. Instead they read: The Federal Bureau of Justice, United States Department of Investigation.
-
- Dean - Hector Aframian, fake credit card
- Dean and Sam - US Marshalls
- Dean and Sam - Troy Squire's uncles
- Dean - Ted Nugent - guitar, bass guitar, vocals; 1958-present
-
- Dean and Sam - Environmental study majors from UC Boulder
- Dean - Samuel Cole, Ranger with the Park Service
- Sam - Ranger with the Park Service
-
- Dean - Agent Ford - Harrison Ford (Han Solo, Star Wars)
- Sam - Agent Hamill - Mark Hamill (Luke Skywalker, Star Wars)
-
- Dean - Dr. James Hetfield - James Hetfield: lead singer and rhythm guitarist of Metallica, 1981-present
-
- Dean and Sam - Day traders who worked with Steven Shoemaker
- Dean and Sam - med students from Ohio State
- Dean and Sam - Reporters asking retired Fort Wayne, Indiana, detective about Mary Worthington
-
- Dean - Bisbee, Arizona, detective
-
- Sam - Sergeant Francis Marquis
- Dean and Sam - Fraternity brothers from Ohio
- Dean and Sam - new students at Eastern Iowa University
-
- Dean and Sam - Dustin Burwash's nephews
- Dean and Sam - prospective house buyers
- Dean - Travis Weaver with the Oklahoma Gas and Power
-
- Dean and Sam - Police detectives, reopening the Winchester disappearance
-
- Dean - Reporter Nigel Tufnel of the Chicago Tribune - Fictional character; lead guitarist of Spinal Tap in This Is Spinal Tap (1984) mockumentary.
-
- Dean - John Bonham - drummer for Led Zeppelin, 1968-1980
-
- Sam (on behalf of Dean) - Mr. Burkovitz, fake insurance card
-
- Dean and Sam - Mr. Anderson's insurance company, All National Mutual
-
- Sam - Detective McCreedy - Fictional character in the horror movies Hobgoblins (1988) and Hobgoblins 2 (2009)
- Dean - Father Simmons - Gene Simmons: vocals and bass guitar for KISS, 1973-present
- Sam - Father Frehley - Paul "Ace" Frehley: vocals and guitar for KISS, 1973-present
-
- Dean - Officer Gregory Washington
-
- Dean and Sam - Alarm Technicians with PF Alarm Systems Chicago USA
-
- Dean and Sam - Reporters with the Dallas Morning News
- Sam - Producer
-
- Dean - Kris Warren, fake credit card
- Sam - Dr. Jerry Caplin, Center for Disease Control
- Dean and Sam - CDC
-
- Dean - Reality TV Scout
- Sam (via Dean) - Producer
- Dean and Sam - Dean and Sam Connors, art dealers, with Connors Limited
-
-
- John, Dean, and Sam all get access to birth records as unspecified officers.
- Sam - neighbor to Holts, down the street
-
- Dean - lives in Sunset Apartments, and owns a Yorkie that pees.
- Dean and Sam - firefighters, in full turn out gear
-
- John - Elroy McGillicuddy, health insurance - Lucy Ricado's maiden name in I Love Lucy; also could be Elspeth McGillicuddy from Agatha Christie's novel 4.50 from Paddington (What Mrs. McGillicuddy Saw)
- Dean and Sam - Elroy McGillicuddy's loving sons