1.18 Something Wicked

In Fitchburg, Wisconsin, Bethany, a young girl, says her prayers before bed. Her father Miles watches at the door and kisses her goodnight. Bethany asks for Mommy coming home, but Dad comments that her mother is at the hospital with her sister. He tells her to sleep tight before leaving. Bethany is obviously scared. Bethany jumps out of bed, races across the room, closes the sheers, and burrows back in bed. A thin, spindly, long fingered hand opens her bedroom window. The figure creeps into the room, the shadow falling across her bed. A hooded figure stands over the girl, and rolls her over. Its mouth gaping, in leans close and a light is emitted. Bethany lets out a scream.

On coordinates from John, Sam and Dean head to Fitchburg, Wisconsin. Sam can't find anything wrong in the town, and doubts there's something to hunt. They arrive in town and Dean stops to get coffee and asks if anything unusual is going on, but still there's nothing. Sam, however, notices there is one kid playing in the park after four and school is out, and points it out to Dean. Dean goes to talk to the mother of the child. The mother mentions that there has been a recent outbreak where five or six kids have gotten hospital sick ill, and the parents think it's catching.

Dean and Sam visit the local hospital posing as doctors from the CDC. As they walk in, Sam confronts Dean about his ID saying Bikini Inspector. Dean comments that she won't even check the ID, for him to have confidence! Dean spins Sam around when they reach the desk, so Sam introduces himself as CDC to the receptionist. To his dismay, the receptionist asks for ID. With Dean silently sniggering down the hall, Sam flashes the ID, hiding part of it, and the receptionist directs them to the pediatrics ward. Sam gives Dean a major bitchface as he passes, telling Dean to follow him. On their way upstairs towards the ward, Dean notices an old lady in one of the rooms with an inverted cross on the wall. She unsettles him.

They soon meet Dr. Hydeker, the doctor on the case, who is surprised to see the CDC here. He tells them it's like pneumonia, but the kids aren't responding to treatment- it's like they seem to have compromised immune systems, and their bodies are wearing out. A nurse appears with papers for the doctor, and explains to the brothers the disease works itself through siblings in a family, but just the kids. Dean asks to speak with the kids, but the nurse tells Dean the children are not conscious. So Dean asks to speak to the parents of the latest victim. Sam and Dean ask questions to Miles, and find out that it was first Mary who got the illness first, then Bethany He blames himself for his daughters getting sick because the window was open in their room, even though he doesn't recall it being open- it's a second story window. Sam isn't sure this is supernatural, so he suggests they go look around the latest victim's home, as it's obvious the parents won't be going home anytime soon.

Dean and Sam check out the girls' room with EMF and UV light, but nothing. Sam eventually looks around the window and finds something on the windowsill. He calls Dean over to show him the semi-human handprint 'rotted' into the window sill.. Dean recognizes it from the past from when he saw it as a kid, which triggers a flashback. A young Dean looks over pictures for John's current hunt, which is the semi-human handprint. John is packing his bag, as he is about to leave for a hunting trip, and he begins to run down the rules again with Dean. Dean recites them perfectly and reminds John he knows all this. John also tells Dean to watch out for Sammy, and leaves. Soon as John leaves the motel room, Dean locks the door. Dean looks at Sammy, who is still watching TV. The flashback ends. Dean tells Sam that Dad had faced this creature before, and wants them to finish the job.

Dean pulls the Impala into a motel parking lot. Getting out, Dean heads to the trunk, and explains to Sam that they are hunting a Shtriga. Dad faced one about sixteen or seventeen years ago in Douglas, Wisconsin. But it got away, which surprises Sam since much doesn't escape John Winchester.Sam pushes Dean to tell him more, but Dean claims he doesn't remember. Dean goes inside to book a room, and is greeted by a smart mouthed young boy named Michael. Michael's mom Joanna comes in and shoos him away to feed his brother Asher dinner. She finishes checking Dean in. As Dean watches, Michael pours milk for Asher and it triggers Dean to have another flashback. Young Dean is getting a meal ready for Sammy. He pours Sammy a glass of milk and gives him spaghettiOs. Sammy is asking when Dad's coming back, which Dean answers tomorrow, usually late. Sammy moans about the food and asks Dean to have Lucky Charms. Dean lies saying there isn't any, but Sammy saw the box. Dean tells Sammy that there is only one bowl and he hasn't had any yet. Sammy gives Dean the puppy dog eyes, so Dean give in. He dumps the contents of Sammy's bowl in the trash, and gives a fresh bowl and the Lucky Charms to Sammy instead of himself. Sammy dives into the box and pulls out the toy, offering it to Dean. Ending the flashback, Joanna brings Dean back to himself, and he signs the credit card receipt.

In the motel room, Sam is researching the Shtriga and confirms that Dean was right. Sam finds that they feed on 'spiritus vitae,' or breath of life, and they are invulnerable to all weapons devised by God and man. Dean corrects Sam, telling him she is vulnerable when she feeds because she can be killed then with consecrated wrought iron buckshot, or rounds, because Dad told him. Sam wonders what else Dad mentioned, but Dean claims that's it. Sam wonders how do they find it, because a Shtriga, when not feeding, can take on human form, usually an old woman. Dean figures out that all the victims are around the hospital, which is in the dead center. Then Dean remembers the old woman from the hospital with the inverted cross, and believes her to be the Shtriga.

Dean and Sam head in the hospital towards the old woman's room, ducking back around the corner to stay hidden from the doctor. When they reach her room, they silently pull out their guns. As Sam is covering her, Dean moves closer to her to check her out. She moves, making dean jump, and quickly accuses them of stealing her stuff. Realizing she isn't the Shtriga they put away their guns and claim to be hospital maintenance, who thought she was asleep.. Believing them, she tells them she tends to sleep 'with her peepers open', and to fix the cross, since she had been asking someone to fix it for a while now.

Meanwhile at the motel, Michael and Asher are sleeping, when the same scrawny hand from before appears and opens the window.

The next morning, Sam and Dean head back to the motel. Sam is still laughing at Dean for almost shooting the innocent old lady. Dean notices Michael sitting outside, upset. Dean approaches him, with Sam following, and asks what's wrong. Michael tells them that his younger brother got sick. Michael's mom appears. She's in a hurry to get to the hospital. Noticing her fluttered state, Dean offers to drive her to the hospital, which she accepts. Before leaving Dean tells Sam that they're going to kill this thing.

While Dean is at the hospital, Sam heads to the library to research the witch. Sam calls Dean, who is still at the hospital, and tells him that he found other reports across the country, hitting a new town every fifteen to twenty years. Dozens of kids, languishing in comas, before they die, all the way back to Black River Falls in the1890s. In one of the articles, Sam finds a picture of Dr. Hydecker from the 1890s. The doctor is their witch! Dean, after hanging up, looks at doctor who is with Asher, comforting Joanna. Hydecker moves to talk to Dean, who is barely able to contain his anger, but doesn't attempt to attack the doctor.

Back at the motel, Dean is still angry, and Sam is surprised that Dean didn't shoot the doctor right there. Dean gave out reasons - not going to open fire in freakin' pediatrics ward, dude's bulletproof unless he's chowing down, and he wasn't packing, which was a good thing because he'd probably had burned a clip on principle alone. Dean tells Sam he knows how to kill it and proposes a plan to use Michael as bait to draw out Hydecker. Sam doesn't like the plan, and Dean tells Sam there isn't any other way, because it could be years before they could get another chance. Dean continues on by saying Dad sent him here, that he screwed up once before. Dean blames himself for its escape, and for the deaths that have occurred since. Sam is confused by this, and sensing Dean knows more about the shtriga than he has revealed, Sam pressures Dean to tell him.

Dean begins to tell Sam what happened the first time, which triggers a flashback.
It has been three days since John left. Dean was getting bored of being cooped up for so long, so he decides to go out for a bit. Before leaving, Dean checks on sleeping Sammy, and then he locks the door before heading to the arcade. The owner closes up, so Dean heads back to the motel room. When he enters, he notices a light turned on from Sammy's room, and slowly walks towards it. He looks in to see Sammy sleeping with the Shtriga above him, and reaches for the shotgun Dad left. Dean aims, but he freezes. John bursts in. Yelling at Dean to get out of the way, he fires at the Shtriga. Obviously hurt, it flees through the window, with John continuously firing after it until he'd emptied his clip. John rushes to check on Sammy, who's sleepy and confused, but otherwise okay. Seeing that Sammy is okay, John wants to know what happened. Dean admits to going out. John yells at Dean for not following his orders, in not leaving the room and not letting Sammy out of his sight. Back to the present, Dean finishes up by saying Dad took them to stay with Pastor Jim about three hours away, but when he returned he couldn't track the shtriga. That after that day, John looked at him differently, but he never spoke of it. Not that Dean blamed him; Dad had given an order and Dean had almost gotten Sammy killed. Dad sent Dean so he can finish the job.

They go to talk to Michael about the thing that attacked Asher. Michael calls them crazy, and threatened to call the cops. Dean, however, tells Michael it came through the window, that he knows what it looks like because it came after his brother. Michael does admit he did see the Shtriga coming for his brother, but thought it to be a nightmare. Dean tells him sometimes nightmares are real, and they need his help to kill it. However, Michael refuses to help.

The boys head back to their room to figure out what to do next since Michael didn't want to help. Sam asks what did Dean expect? It's scary for an adult, much less a kid. A knock at the door shows it's Michael. Michael asks if they kill this thing, will Asher get better? Dean honestly tells Michael he doesn't know. Michael asks Dean if he would do anything for his little brother. Dean answers yes. Michael tells Dean he would too, and he'll help.

That night, Dean places a video camera on bookshelves in Michael's bedroom, lining it up to face the bed and window with directions from Sam, who's watching the feed from the laptop as they need to wait until the shtriga starts feeding before they can attack. Dean then goes over with Michael to talk with him - stay under the covers until they come in with guns, then roll off the bed and crawl under it. To hide under the bed when they start shooting. Michael voices his worries about getting shot, but Dean assures him that they won't miss, but the gunshots will be a lot louder than the movies.

It's now 3 am, and the brothers are still waiting in the living room for the Shtriga to show up. Sam attempts to apologize to Dean for always giving him hell for following Dad's orders, which causes Dean to groan in annoyance. Then the creature comes, and approaches Michael. Sam wants to go immediately, but Dean tells him to wait. Just as it starts to feed on Michael, Sam and Dean burst in. After Dean yells down for Michael, they fire repeatedly on it. It falls down. The boys let their guards down, and the creature attacks. It throws Dean across the room. Turning to Sam, it throws him against the wall, falling on the bed. Jumping on Sam, it chokes him, forces his mouth open, and begins to feed. Sam, helpless, is fed upon, until Dean yells, bringing up the Shriga's attention, and shoots it between the eyes. Dean asks 'You okay little brother?' Thumbs up from Sam is his response. Dean shoots the creature a couple more times for good measure and it disintegrates away. Unharmed, Michael climbs out from under the bed.

The next morning, Sam and Dean are packing up, when Joanna appears looking for Michael. When he comes running over to hug her, she tells him and the brothers that Asher will be fine, as well as the other children, and soon the ward will be like a ghost town. Dr. Hydecker has disappeared. Michael wants to see Asher, so Joanna drives them to the hospital. Sam tells Dean it's sad that Michael will always know there are things out there in the dark. He sometimes wishes he was innocent too. Dean admits sometimes he wishes Sam were innocent too. They drive off.