2.03 Bloodlust

A girl, Christina Flannigan, is running through the woods, being chased by something. She trips, but gets back up and keeps going. She hides behind a tree as the pursuer runs past. Relaxing, she comes out. She turns around and there's someone standing there, holding a long curved knife. The hooded person chops off her head, and her body falls down.

Back in the newly restored Impala, Dean is in a great mood. He's got his car and a case. Sam snarks back at him, which Dean laughs at. It's another 300 miles to Red Lodge, and Dean happily presses the gas pedal to the metal.

The boys are impersonating reporters from Weekly World News, asking the sheriff questions about the murders. When he is signaled to leave, they ask about the possible Satanic rituals concerning the cattle with the murders. He laughs, until he realizes they were serious. After explaining why the cows couldn't be mutilated, he asks what newspaper they worked for. Dean stumbles over the name, and while Sam tries to correct him, the sheriff runs them out of his office.

Dressed in white lab coats, Dean and Sam enter the morgue and claims the doctor wants to see the intern. After buying the story, he rushes out, leaving the boys alone in the morgue. Asking if the satanists in Florida marked their victims', Dean grabs gloves for both of them. Sam replies yes, on the forehead, so when they pull out the victim Dean grabs the box. They taunt each other, before Dean opens the lid. Finding no mark, after taunting each other again, Sam reaches in the mouth to check for anything. Claiming he's going to puke, Sam finishes his exam and pulls his fingers out. However Dean notices something, and pushes on the gum when a vampire fang descends. This changes things.

Dean and Sam find a bar, and go inside to question the bartender. After ordering a couple of beers, the boys asks him for any night owls that party all night. Sam slides him a $50, so when he takes it he lets them know about a farm leased out. The boys thank him, before leaving. The man who notices them come in, is missing when they leave.

The man from the bar follows the boys around back, down an alley, where he loses them. After searching a bit, he is surprised by Dean and Sam pressing him against the wall, with Dean holding a knife to his throat. After showing them his teeth, Gordon Walker and the Winchesters exchange names. He's impressed by them, mentioning their dad, saying he was a great hunter and had big shoes to fill. He offers sympathy John passed, but then says they fill his shoes as good trackers and good in a tight spot. Dean wonders how Gordon seems to know a lot about their family, and Gordon tells them that word travels fast, because hunters talk. Dean tells him they don't know hunters, and Gordon says he guesses there was a lot their dad never told them. Sam asks him if he'd killed the two vampires. Gordon replies yes, he'd been here for two weeks, and the Barker farm was just hippie freaks. Dean asks about the nest, but Gordon tells them this one is covered. He's been tracking them over a year, that he found a vampire in Austin and tracked it here. Dean offers to help wanting a hunt, but Gordon says he'll finish it himself, offering them a hunt for a Chupacabra two states over. Telling them it was good meeting them and promising to buy them a drink on the flip side, Gordon drives away as the brothers watch.

A security man at the mill, Conrad, hears a noise and gets up to investigate. After searching through the mill, Gordon jumps him. As the two fight, Conrad shows his fangs and eventually turns on the electric saw. After a brutal fight, Conrad pushes Gordon down to cut off his head but Sam grabs Gordon out of harm's way. With Conrad's attention on Sam, Dean attacks the vampire, pinning him down to the belt and using the saw to behead him. Gordon offers to buy Dean that drink, although Sam is concerned over Dean.

At the bar, Gordon buys the first round of drinks between him and Dean, both of them celebrating the kill. Dean asks Sammy if he's alright, and he says he's fine. Gordon tells Sammy to lighten up. After telling Gordon only Dean gets to call him Sammy, Sam decides he's going back to the hotel because he doesn't feel that decapitations are a good time and doesn't want to drag them down. Dean tosses Sam the keys, assuring Gordon Sam just gets that way and looking forward to playing quarters with Gordon.

Back at the motel Sam puts the car keys on the desk.

With Gordon, Dean recounts a hunt. After the hunt, Dean's thinking how he's seeing things other kids will never know or dream of. So that's when he embraced the life. Gordon described how he got into hunting at 18, when a vampire came after his sister and flung Gordon across the room. He went after the fang, figured out how to track and kill it; it was his first kill. He misses his sister, then the conversation turns to Dean talking about his Dad. How indestructible he was, until he was gone. Dean can't talk to Sam about it, but he's not handling it well. Gordon tells him to take that hole inside him and use it to do his job of killing things. Not a crime to need his job.

Sam calls Ellen, asking about Gordon. Ellen knows Gordon and he's a good hunter, but when she find out that Sam and Dean are working with him she warns him away because he's dangerous to everyone and everything around him. She says if he's working on a job then they'd better just let him handle it and move on.

Gordon loves the hunting life, because there's no maybe - all black and white. Dean's not sure Sam would agree, and Gordon points out that he's different. But Dean and he were born to the life, it's in their blood. Dean's thoughtful over that revelation.

Sam's buying a soda at the motel, and heading back to the room when he hears a noise. He checks his surroundings, and again right before going into the room. Once there he puts his soda down, relaxing, when he's jumped from behind by a vampire. Sam hits him, when a second vampire jumps him. He dispatches the second vampire, but before he could turn around the first one hits Sam over the head with a phone. Sam is knocked out.

Sam wakes up in the nest, gagged with a bag over his head. He recognizes the bartender, as he shows Sam his fangs and advances. A girl calls out to stop the vampire, walking over to Sam to yank the gag off as well. Lenore introduces herself, and tells Sam they need to talk. At first Sam has problems because of Eli's teeth, and laughs at her word he won't be hurt. She tells him they aren't like other vampires because they don't kill humans or drink their blood - haven't for a long time. They've been the ones drinking cattle blood, and it's disgusting. They do this to survive, because their kind is practically extinct. Eli is furious at even trying to talk with that killer, since Conrad was murdered and they celebrated. She tells him enough, and tells Sam they were leaving. The reason Sam was brought because once hunters have the scent they'll keep tracking, but Lenore is asking them not to follow. That they have a right to live. Sam's not sure to believe her, but she promises to let him go without a scratch. He's blindfolded and led out.

Dean and Gordon are looking at a map back at the motel. Gordon is showing him where he thinks the nest is, as the two strategize. Dean checks his watch and wonders where Sam is. Gordon guesses Sam went out for a walk. As Dean is wondering, Sam walks in, and rather than answer where he'd been, he asks to talk with Dean alone.

Outside the motel Sam tells Dean they should rethink the hunt. Sam tells him that he was at the nest, that they found him. Dean asks him how'd he get out and how many he killed, but Sam says none - that they just let him go. Dean wants to know where the nest is, but Sam claims he was blindfolded and doesn't know. Sam pushes Dean not to go after them, because they aren't killing people - they stay alive with cattle blood. Dean doesn't quite believe them, even though Sam was released without a scratch. Dean wants to find them and kill them. Gordon is standing around the corner in the shadows listening, but they don't see him. Dean's argument is if it's supernatural, they kill it, it's their job. Sam says no, they're job is hunting evil, and these things aren't killing people so they're not evil. Dean wants to exterminate them all, but Sam insists not this time. Dean finally says Gordon has been on them for a year, so he knows. Sam counters that Ellen says he's bad news. Dean says he's not listening to Ellen, they barely know her. Sam points out that Dean is using Gordon as a poor substitute for Dad. Dean starts to walk away but Sam calls Dean on his crap. Dean's slapping a big fake smile on, but Sam knows Dad's death left a hole, so stop filling that hole with whoever you want because it's insulting Dad's memory. Dean punches Sam in the face. Sam tells him he can hit him all he wants, but it's not going to change anything. Dean tells him he's going to the nest, he'll find it himself.

They go back into the motel, and find that Gordon is gone. Both agree to go after him, but Dean's still not sure about stopping Gordon. The keys to Dean's car are gone, so Dean hotwires the Impala. Sam figures out the directions, with the help of a local map, by retracing how long each section of the drive was and the different turns. Dean tells him he's good, a monster pain in the ass, but good.

Lenore is packing, then Eli comes in to talk. He wants to stay and fight, but Lenore says no. She points out there's more of them, and therefore wants to reason. Eli counters there's no reasoning with them. She says she's not giving up hope that hunters change, before sending Eli into town to gather the others, because they're leaving before sunrise.

Gordon is driving to the nest, guessing which turn to take after the bridge. Dean and Sam are close behind him, following Sam's memory and directions. They take the same turn.

Lenore is packing the truck. Turning around, Gordon is there, grabbing her. He stabs her in the chest with a knife covered in dead man's blood.

Gordon tied Lenore up, and he is torturing her by cutting her with the knife, dipped in dead man's blood. Dean and Sam come in. Gordon brags he's going to get Lenore to tell him where the rest of them are, offering them to help him as he cuts away the fingers. They're at a stand-off as Sam tries to get Gordon to stop, but Gordon wants to finish the nest - no shades of grey. Gordon tells them his sister was turned, and he hunted her down himself. Sam realizes Gordon knew all along these vampires weren't killing anyone. Gordon counters saying vampires don't change and he can prove it. He grabs Sam's arm, cuts it, and maneuvers Sam's arm above Lenore. Dean aims a gun at Gordon, but Gordon says he isn't going to kill Sam, just making a point. As Sam's blood drips onto her, her vampire fangs come out, and she is growling and hissing. Gordon says they're all the same - evil, bloodthirsty. However, Lenore's fangs retract and she resolves to say no. Sam pushes a stunned Gordon away, before he unties Lenore and takes her out. Dean says that he thinks Gordon and he have some things to talk about. Dean is having a hard time believing it, but he now believes Sam and is protecting the vampires so if Gordon wants the vampires, he has to go through him. Gordon fights Dean, after he first puts down his knife. Dean starts to put away his gun, and Gordon attacks. He grabs his knife, so Dean is forced to knock it out of Gordon's hand. As they fight, they talk back and forth - Gordon talking about how Dean is a killer like him and not like his brother, but Dean doesn't think so as he gains the upper hand and half knocks Gordon out. Dean ties up Gordon.

It's morning; Sam comes back in, letting Dean know all the vampires got out. Dean replies Sam didn't miss much there, before telling Gordon that he'll call someone in a couple of days to come and untie him. Before Dean's ready to go, he punches Gordon one more time, knocking the chair to the floor. Now he's ready to go.

As the boys leave the nest, Dean offers for Sam to hit him, as a freebie. Sam refuses, saying Dean looks as if he just went twelve rounds with a block of cement, and he'll take a raincheck. Dean says he wishes they never took this job, wondering how many things they killed that didn't deserve it. He hates those things now, even enjoying killing the vampire at the mill. Sam says that after Mom died, Dad did the best he could, and pointed out that Dean didn't kill Lenore. Doesn't matter every instinct of Dean's said to kill them, he didn't so that's what matters. Dean said it was only because Sam's such a pain in his ass. Sam smiling, said he'll stick around to be a pain in the ass. Dean thanks him before Sam climbs into the car. Dean looks back at the house for a few seconds, and then he climbs in the car. They drive away.